| 1999-2000 ALL-AMERICAN TEAM | | |
| | |
| FIRST TEAM | SECOND TEAM | THIRD TEAM |
| Ajamu Gaines, Charleson (WV) | Ewan Auguste, Washburn | Cory Brathol, Northern Michigan |
| Leroy John, Kentucky Wesleyan | T.J. Trimboli, Southern Conn. | Paul Talbot, Wingate |
| Innocent Kere, Florida Southern | Ron Selleaze, Cal State Bakersfield | New Sovle, Pfeiffer |
| DeMarco Anzures, Metro State (CO) | Seth Martin, California (PA) | Josh Quigley, Minnesota-Duluth |
| Geoff Brower, Lander | Nathan Blessen, South Dakota | Chad Mustard, North Dakota |
| | Tarrie Monroe, Lewis |
| | Quincy Stinson, Cal State Los Angeles |
| | |
| 2000-01 ALL-AMERICAN TEAM | | |
| | | |
| FIRST TEAM | SECOND TEAM | THIRD TEAM |
| Ewan Auguste, Washburn | Niki Arinze, Henderson State | Marlon Dawson, Central Oklahoma |
| Colin Ducharme, Longwood | Kyle Behrens, North Dakota | Lamar Gayle, Cal State Bakersfield |
| Lorico Duncan, Ky. Wesleyan | Javar Cheathum, Gannon | Scott Koenen, Southwest State |
| Ryan McCormack, Adelphi | J.R. Gamble, Queens | Derrick Lyons, Southern Indiana |
| Wiyle Petty, Johnson C. Smith | Todd Roberts, Saint Michael's | Wes Pitlock, Northeastern State |
| Daniel Willis, Lenior-Rhyme | |
| | | |
| 2001-02 ALL-AMERICAN TEAM | | |
| | | |
| FIRST TEAM | SECOND TEAM | THIRD TEAM |
| Niki Arinze, Henderson State | Jerome Beasley, North Dakota | Tyrus Boswell, Kentucky Wesleyan |
| Ronald Evans, Ky. Wesleyan | Jon Brown, Tampa | Ronald Curry, CS Bakersfield |
| Malik Moore, American Intl. | Bobby Burries, CS San Bernardino | Al Elliot, Pace |
| Ronald Murray, Shaw | Ronald Johnson, CS Los Angeles | Danny Jones, Tarleton State |
| Kenny Tate, Edinboro | Jon Shepard, Northeastern Okla. | Dennis Mims, Indiana (PA) |
| | | |
| 2002-03 ALL-AMERICAN TEAM | | |
| | | |
| FIRST TEAM | SECOND TEAM | THIRD TEAM |
| Sotirios Karapostolou, Southern New Hampshire | Danny Jones, Tarleton State | Elad Inbar, Massachusetts-Lowell |
| Jerome Beasley, North Dakota | Wykeen Kelly, Salem International | Tommie King, South Dakota |
| Jon Shepherd, Northeastern State | Aaron Farley, Harding | Marlon Parmer, Kentucky Wesleyan |
| Matt Cameron, Michigan Tech | Bobby Burries, Cal State-San Bernardino | Ronald Johnson, Cal State-L.A. |
| Ramzee Stanton, West Chester (Pa.) | Marco Spears, Johnson C. Smith | Tim Washington, Bowie State |
| 2003-04 ALL-AMERICAN TEAM | |
| | |
| STUDENT-ATHLETE | INSTITUTION |
| Elad Inbar | Massachusetts-Lowell |
| Tommie King | South Dakota |
| Terrence Hill | Kennesaw State |
| Darnell Hinson | Northeastern State |
| Mike Taylor | West Virginia State |
| Jonathan Levy | Cal State-San Bernardino |
| Josh Buettner | Michigan Tech |
| Tarvoris Uzoique | Henderson State |
| Romuald Augustin | Bryant College |
| Charles Hanks | Bemidji State |
| Yandel Brown | Columbus State |
| Tim Burnette | Tarleton State |
| Lewis Muse | Concord |
| Austin Nichols | Humbolt State |
| Monta McGhee | Lewis |
| Billy McDaniel | Arkansas-Monticello |
| 2004-05 ALL-AMERICAN TEAM | |
| | |
| STUDENT-ATHLETE | INSTITUTION |
| Stacey Moragne | Massachusetts-Lowell |
| Josh Buettner | Michigan Tech. |
| Brad Oleson | Alaska-Anchorage |
| Jamel Staten | Minnesota State-Mankato |
| James Hall | Montevallo |
| Jakim Donaldson | Edinboro |
| Letheal Cook | Bowie State |
| Eddie Jackson | Pittsburg State |
| Tim Forbes | Bentley |
| David Logan | Indianapolis |
| Jeff Bonds | Cal-Poly Pomona |
| Turner Trofholz | South Dakota |
| Marcus Kennedy | Montevallo |
| Lewis Muse | Concord |
| Jaaber Lugman | Virginia Union |
| Travis Robbins | Washburn |
| Mark Worthington | Metropolitan State |
| Rico Grier | Pfeiffer |
| Yandel Brown | Columbus State |
| 2005-06 ALL-AMERICAN TEAM | |
| | |
| STUDENT-ATHLETE | INSTITUTION |
| Darius Hargrove | Virginia Union |
| Duane Crockett | Virginia Union |
| Sheldon Pace | Southwest Baptist |
| Michael Hicks | Central Missouri State |
| Turner Trofholz | South Dakota |
| Luke Anderson | Minnesota State-Mankato |
| Sullivan Sykes | Saint Joseph's |
| Dustin Pfeifer | Findlay |
| Shaun McKie | Salem International |
| DeMario Grier | Pfeiffer |
| Jasper Johnson | Delta State |
| Jason Smith | Alabama-Huntsville |
| Grant Dykstra | Western Washington |
| Tony Binetti | Seattle Pacific |
| Stacey Moragne | Massachusetts-Lowell |
| Tayron Thomas | Philadelphia |
| 2006-07 ALL-AMERICAN TEAM | |
| | |
| STUDENT-ATHLETE | INSTITUTION |
| Christian Burns | Philadelphia University |
| Steve Dagostino | College of St. Rose |
| Ted Scott | West Virginia State |
| Anthony Atkinson | Barton |
| Gail Goodrich | Bowie State |
| Tyrekus "A.J." Bowman | Augusta State |
| Frank Phillips | Findlay |
| Ricky Volcy | Northern Michigan |
| John Smith | Winona State |
| Luke Anderson | Minnesota State-Mankato |
| Marcus Kennedy | Montevallo |
| Greg Brown | Montevallo |
| Eric Babers | Southeastern Oklahoma |
| Damien Lolar | West Texas A&M |
| Kevin Johnson | Humboldt State |
| Dustin Bremerman | Seattle Pacific |
| 2007-08 ALL-AMERICAN TEAM | |
| | |
| STUDENT-ATHLETE | INSTITUTION |
| Carl Arts | Alaska Anchorage |
| Sam Belt | Central Oklahoma |
| Jeremy Black | Tampa |
| Josh Bostic | Findlay |
| Tyrekus "A.J." Bowman | Augusta State |
| Chris Gilliam | Pitt-Johnstown |
| Chris Commons | USC Aiken |
| Steve Dagostino | St. Rose |
| Callistus Eziukwu | Grand Valley |
| Nate Fritsch | Bentley |
| Robert Lee | West Texas A&M |
| Charlie Parker | Millersville |
| Devin Peal | Humboldt State |
| Jonny Reibel | Rollins |
| Atila Santos | Minnesota State-Mankato |
| John Smith | Winona State |
