National Honors
UPS Coach of the Year - NAIA - By Year
| 1993 | Gerald Stockton | Midwestern State |
| 1994 | Jim Reid | Georgetown (Ky.) |
| 1995 | Duane Reboul | Birmingham Southern |
| 1996 | Larry Holley | William Jewell |
| 1997 | Roger Kaiser | Life |
| 1998 | Bobby Martin | Southern Nazarene |
| 1999 | Kim Elders | Cornerstone |
| 2000 | Roger Kaiser | Life |
| 2001 | Don Lane | Transylvania |
| 2002 | Harry Statham | McKendree |
| 2003 | Ken Amman | Concordia |
| 2004 | Bob Bolen | Mountain State |
| 2005 | Not Awarded |
| 2006 | Terry Waldrop | Texas Wesleyan |
| 2007 | Rocky Lamar | Mid-America Nazarene |
| 2008 | Ray Harper | Oklahoma City University |
| NAIA | Division I |
| 2009 | Ralph Turner | Union (Tenn.) |
| 2010 | Bob Bolen | Mountain State (W. Va.) |
| NAIA | Division II |
| 2009 | Donnie Bostwick | Oklahoma Wesleyan |
| 2010 | Donnie Bostwick | Oklahoma Wesleyan |
